• Listing status icon


  • 2/27/17 | MLS#: A4166499
  • 2Beds
  • 2Baths
  • 2,929Sq Ft



Listing provided courtesy of: Berkshire Hathaway HomeService


One of 4 contiguous properties now available on our wonderful Palm Island on Siesta Key. History abounds being owned by the world renowned artist, Thornton Utz, the third resident of Palm Island. Thornton, one of the most successful cover artists of the 1950's most notably for the Saturday Evening Post. His family recall and share heartfelt stories of how Thornton and Maud loved living on Siesta Key… the one-half mile proximity to the crystal sands of Siesta Key beach, the ability to build and grow their family compound with unique designs, re-purposing wood and metals, creating something only an artist at heart could do. It is here that Thornton painted Norman Rockwell and his grand-daughter. Structures need work. Actual sq footage may differ. This being the largest parcel of over 11,000 sq ft. corner lot. The unique round home has multi-levels and Mexican tile & bamboo floors a loft with ship style railing, starburst beamed ceilings, 2-3 bedrooms with a framed shed on site. Grand old trees and tropical foliage abound. See 5323 Calle Florida, 121 Island Circle and Lot 33 Calle Florida. A total of 33,000 sq feet. Survey available. Tenant in place through 4/30/2017 and would like to remain.

General Features

  • County Or Parish Sarasota
  • Disclosures Lead Paint
  • Other Structures Shed(s)
  • Pets Allowed Yes
  • Subdivision Name SARASOTA BEACH
  • Year Built 1955
  • Zoning RSF2

Building Features

  • Appliances Other
  • Architectural Style Other
  • Full Bathrooms 2
  • Building Area Source Public Records
  • Building Area Total 2,929
  • Construction Materials Stone, Wood Frame
  • Cooling Central Air
  • Exterior Features Balcony
  • Flooring Ceramic Tile, Wood
  • Foundation Details Slab
  • Heating Central
  • Interior Features Other
  • Living Area 2000.00
  • Levels Two
  • Roof Built-Up, Other
  • Room Count 7

Property Features

  • Lot Size Square Feet 11450
  • Property Condition Fixer
  • Total Acreage 1/4 Acre to 21779 Sq. Ft.
  • Vegetation Mature Landscaping, Trees/Landscaped
  • Lot Features In County
  • Lot Size Acres 0.26


  • Elementary School Phillippi Shores Elementary
  • Middle Or Junior School Brookside Middle
  • High School Sarasota High

Ask a Question

Days on Market

  • This property was listed on the market for 45 days
  • Average days-on-market for homes between $460,000 - $690,000 = 119 (in zip code 34242)


The property map location is: Accurate, based on Google's address match.

Walk Score

Get the Walk Score Report

Home Valuation

Get the Home Value Report

Ask A Question

Community Demographics for Zip Code 34242 (SARASOTA)

Housing Occupancy
  • Home Owners: 4,162 (32%)
  • Renters: 575 (4%)
  • Vacant: 8,258 (64%)
  • Total Housing Units: 12,995
  • Average Household Size: 1.89
  • Housing Density (People per square mile): 2,493
Age Range (number of people)
  • Age 0-14: 723
  • Age 15-24: 502
  • Age 25-39: 710
  • Age 40-59: 1,362
  • Age 60-79: 2,975
  • Age 80+: 2,703
  • Total: 8,975

* All numbers in this section are 2016 projections provided by Geolytics Inc

School Information for 34242 (SARASOTA)

Private Schools in Zip Code 34242 (SARASOTA)

* This list of schools may not match the property above.

Out Of Door Academy 444 Reid St. Sarasota, FL 34242 Phone: 9413493223 PreK-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 35
  • Knd: 53
  • 1st: 59
  • 2nd: 55
  • 3rd: 49
  • 4th: 52
  • 5th: 54
  • 6th: 49
  • 7th: 58
  • 8th: 27
  • 9th: 27
  • 10th: 36
  • 11th: 59
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 596

* School data provided by US Department of Education

Listing information provided in part by the IDX Program of My Florida Regional MLS. All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified. Data last updated on 4/21/2018 6:16 PM PST.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

* Rates and payment information listed in the mortgage calculator are provided as for general reference only. Specific mortgage information should be verified with a qualified lending professional