• Listing status icon


  • Active | MLS#: A4166484
  • 3Beds
  • 4Baths
  • 2,517Sq Ft


Info Visit Search


One of 4 contiguous properties, all deeded separately, now available on our wonderful Palm Island on Siesta Key. History abounds being owned by the world renowned artist, Thornton Utz, the third resident of Palm Island. Thornton, one of the most successful cover artists of the 1950’s most notably for the Saturday Evening Post. His family recalls and share heartfelt stories of how they loved living on Siesta Key… biking around the island, walking to crystal sands of Siesta Key beach, how they grew the family compound with unique designs, re-purposing wood and metals, creating something only an artist at heart could do. Most of the value is in the land. Structure needs work but has character not found in today's homes. This tropical haven offers 4 bedrooms and 4 baths, an in-ground pool, multi-levels, a rounded shaped kitchen, bright and large master with electric awning to enjoy the stars and moon, last added to in 1985, half stairs up to living room with dry bar, deck and loft accessed by ships ladder, some central air, some wall A/C, separate office/garage, canopied trees and brick walks. Actual sq footage may differ. Such a peaceful setting yet minutes away from shopping, dining, downtown Sarasota and more. Abuts vacant Lot 33 – buy together for a great parcel. See 121 Island Circle, 123 Island Circle and Lot 33 Calle Florida. A total of 33,000 sq feet if 4 are purchased together. Survey available. District). Tenant in place through 12/31/2016. Ample time required for showings

Listing provided courtesy of: BERKSHIRE HATHAWAY HOMESERVICE

General Features

  • Property Style Single Family Home
  • County Or Parish Sarasota
  • Financing Available Cash
  • Housing For Older Persons N/A
  • MLS Area Major Sarasota/Crescent Beach/Siesta Key
  • Tax Year 2015
  • Taxes 6595
  • Township 37
  • Year Built 1960

Building Features

  • Architectural Style Custom
  • Appliances Included Other
  • Air Conditioning Central
  • Property Description Two Story
  • Floor Covering Carpet, Ceramic Tile
  • Foundation Slab
  • Heatingand Fuel Central
  • Interior Features Built in Features, Dry Bar
  • Interior Layout Eating Space In Kitchen
  • Pool Private
  • Pool Type In Ground
  • Roof Metal, Other
  • Sq Ft Heated 2,517
  • Sq Ft Total 4044

Property Features

  • Exterior Construction Block, Wood Frame
  • Exterior Features Mature Landscaping, Patio/Porch/Deck Open, Screen/Covered Enclosure, Sliding Doors
  • Location In County, Street Paved
  • Lot Number 34
  • Lot Size Acres 0.2
  • Lot Size Sq Ft 8619
  • Total Acreage Up to 10, 889 Sq. Ft.
  • Utilities BB/HS Internet Avail, County Water, Public Sewer


  • Elementary School Phillippi Shores Elementary
  • Middle School Brookside Middle
  • High School Sarasota High

Ask a Question

Price & Status History

Days on Market

  • This property has been listed on the market for 98 days
  • Average days-on-market for homes between $480,000 - $720,000 = 175 (in zip code 34242)


The property map location is: Accurate, based on Google's address match.

Walk Score

Get the Walk Score Report

Home Valuation

Get the Home Value Report
Share Report

Share this report with a friend

Get Monthly Update

Save my Home Value Report

Updated report will be emailed every 4 weeks.

Ask A Question


Days on Market

Community Demographics for Zip Code 34242 (SARASOTA)

  • Housing Occupancy

    Home Owners
    Total Housing Units
  • Households

    Average Household Size
    Housing Density (People per square mile)

Age Range (number of people)

Age 0-14
Age 15-24
Age 25-39
Age 40-59
Age 60-79
Age 80+

* All numbers in this section are 2016 projections provided by Geolytics Inc

School Information for 34242 (SARASOTA)

Private Schools in Zip Code 34242 (SARASOTA)

* This list of schools may not match the property above.

  • Out Of Door Academy
    444 Reid St. Sarasota, FL 34242
    Phone: 9413493223
  • Grade Size Distribution
    • PreK
    • 35
    • Knd
    • 53
    • 1st
    • 59
    • 2nd
    • 55
    • 3rd
    • 49
    • 4th
    • 52
    • 5th
    • 54
    • 6th
    • 49
    • 7th
    • 58
    • 8th
    • 27
    • 9th
    • 27
    • 10th
    • 36
    • 11th
    • 59
    • Teachers: 0
    • Students per Teacher: N/A
    • Students: 596

* School data provided by US Department of Education

Listing information provided in part by the IDX Program of MFRMLS. All listing information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified through personal inspection by appropriate professionals. Listings displayed on this website may be subject to prior sale or removal from sale; availability of any listing should always be independently verified. Data last updated on 1/16/2017 6:18 PM PST.

Listing information is provided for consumer personal, non-commercial use, solely to identify potential properties for potential purchase; all other use is strictly prohibited and may violate relevant federal and state law.

* Rates and payment information listed in the mortgage calculator are provided as for general reference only. Specific mortgage information should be verified with a qualified lending professional