• Listing status icon

    $5,495,000

  • Active | MLS#: 123580
  • 7Beds
  • 9Baths
  • 6,888Sq Ft

425 Caroline Street KEY WEST, FL 33040

Favorite
Share
Close
Info Visit Search

Overview

An extraordinarily handsome Old Town estate that offers unparalleled craftsmanship, beautiful architecture, the finest amenities and a very rich history. Immaculately manicured and in impeccable condition, the home and guest quarters total 7BR/8.5BA including a 2BR/2BA guest house and all resting on a huge 14,701 sf lot, just steps from world-famous Duval St. Expansiveporches, 13' ceilings,

Listing provided courtesy of: Truman & Co. (KW)

General Features

  • Acreage 0.34
  • Square Footage 6,888
  • Building Style Conch
  • Stories 3 Stories
  • As Is Right to Inspect Yes
  • HOA No
  • Association Approval Required No
  • Deed Restrictions Unknown
  • Key Island Key West
  • KW Neighborhood Old Town-N of Truman
  • Subdivision Old Town - Unlisted (1.0)
  • Off Shore Island No
  • Pets Pets Not Applicable
  • Potential Short Sale No
  • Bank Owned No
  • Rentals Allowed Yes
  • Taxes $41,906
  • Tax Year 2015

Building Features

  • Appliances Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Freezer, Gas Appliances, Microwave, Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appl, Washer
  • Cooling/Heating Ceiling Fans, Central A/C, Combination A/C, Heat
  • Interior Features Built-in Cabinets, Fireplace(s), Granite Counter Top, Pantry, Smoke Alarms, Storage, Walk-in Closet
  • Construction Frame
  • Flooring Marble, Tile Floor, Wood Floor
  • Furnished Furniture Negotiable
  • Porch/Balcony Patio
  • Roofing Metal Roof
  • Shutters Other
  • Windows/Doors French Doors, Glass Doors, Single Hung Windows, Wood Windows

Room Features

  • Specialty Rooms Utility Room, Workshop

Property Features

  • Exterior Features Detached Guest Qtrs, Fencing, Gazebo, Gutters, Landscape Lighting, Outdoor Kitchen, Sprinkler System, Storage
  • Garage Spaces 4+
  • Garage/Parking Off Street Parking
  • Pool Yes
  • Pool Heated Yes
  • Pool Info Concrete, In Ground
  • Security Electric Gate
  • Side Median
  • Water View No Waterview
  • Waterfront Property No
  • Utilities FKAA, Municipal Sewer, Propane Gas
  • Pub Sewer HkUp Yes

Ask a Question

Price & Status History

Days on Market

  • This property has been listed on the market for 356 days
  • Average days-on-market for homes between $4,396,000 - $6,594,000 = 356 (in zip code 33040)

Location

The property map location is: Accurate, based on Google's address match.

Walk Score

Get the Walk Score Report

Home Valuation

Get the Home Value Report

Ask A Question

Community Demographics for Zip Code 33040 (KEY WEST)

Housing Occupancy
  • Home Owners: 6,966 (40%)
  • Renters: 8,438 (49%)
  • Vacant: 1,884 (11%)
  • Total Housing Units: 17,288
Households
  • Average Household Size: 2.26
  • Housing Density (People per square mile): 1,959
Age Range (number of people)
  • Age 0-14: 5,412
  • Age 15-24: 3,184
  • Age 25-39: 5,013
  • Age 40-59: 10,349
  • Age 60-79: 9,563
  • Age 80+: 2,709
  • Total: 36,230

* All numbers in this section are 2016 projections provided by Geolytics Inc

School Information for 33040 (KEY WEST)

Public Schools in Zip Code 33040 (KEY WEST)

* This list of schools may not match the property above.

KEY WEST HIGH SCHOOL 2100 FLAGLER AVE KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931549 9th-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • 9th: 441
  • 10th: 378
  • 11th: 311
  • 12th: 280
School Population
  • Teachers: 105
  • Students per Teacher: 13.4
  • Students: 1410
  • Male/Female: 738/630
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
KEYS CENTER 5901 COLLEGE RD KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931400 8th-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • 9th: 2
  • 10th: 8
  • 11th: 3
  • 12th: 3
School Population
  • Teachers: 4
  • Students per Teacher: 4.0
  • Students: 16
  • Male/Female: 0/14
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
ADULT/VOCATIONAL/COMMUNITY EDUCATION 2100 FLAGLER AVE4-108 KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931549 7th-12th
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 0
  • Male/Female: 0/0
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
KEY WEST DETENTION CENTER 5501 COLLEGE RD KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052937300 7th-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • 7th: 1
  • 9th: 2
  • 10th: 1
  • 12th: 1
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 5
  • Male/Female: 4/1
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
HORACE O'BRYANT MIDDLE SCHOOL 1105 LEON ST KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052965628 6th-8th
Grade Size Distribution
  • 6th: 225
  • 7th: 255
  • 8th: 232
School Population
  • Teachers: 58
  • Students per Teacher: 12.3
  • Students: 712
  • Male/Female: 372/312
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
MAY SANDS SCHOOL 1400 UNITED ST KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931400 6th-12th
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 0
  • Male/Female: 0/0
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
MONTESSORI ELEMENTARY CHARTER SCHOOL 1127 UNITED ST KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052944910 1st-5th
Grade Size Distribution
  • 1st: 14
  • 2nd: 20
  • 3rd: 20
  • 4th: 19
  • 5th: 11
School Population
  • Teachers: 5
  • Students per Teacher: 16.8
  • Students: 84
  • Male/Female: 33/47
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
GERALD ADAMS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 5855 WEST COLLEGE RD KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931610 PreK-5th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 67
  • Knd: 59
  • 1st: 78
  • 2nd: 74
  • 3rd: 78
  • 4th: 63
  • 5th: 74
School Population
  • Teachers: 44
  • Students per Teacher: 11.2
  • Students: 493
  • Male/Female: 251/225
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
GLYNN ARCHER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 1302 WHITE ST KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931600 PreK-5th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 82
  • Knd: 49
  • 1st: 42
  • 2nd: 38
  • 3rd: 31
  • 4th: 40
  • 5th: 33
School Population
  • Teachers: 28
  • Students per Teacher: 11.3
  • Students: 315
  • Male/Female: 171/136
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
POINCIANA ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 1407 KENNEDY DR KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052931630 PreK-5th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 18
  • Knd: 94
  • 1st: 91
  • 2nd: 105
  • 3rd: 107
  • 4th: 93
  • 5th: 103
School Population
  • Teachers: 42
  • Students per Teacher: 14.5
  • Students: 611
  • Male/Female: 301/293
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278
SIGSBEE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL 939 FELTON RD KEY WEST, FL 33040 Phone: 3052941861 PreK-5th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 27
  • Knd: 43
  • 1st: 47
  • 2nd: 34
  • 3rd: 46
  • 4th: 27
  • 5th: 34
School Population
  • Teachers: 18
  • Students per Teacher: 14.3
  • Students: 258
  • Male/Female: 118/123
School District
  • MONROE
  • 241 TRUMBO RD KEY WEST, FL 33040
  • Phone: 3052931400
District Population
  • Schools: 26
  • Full-Time Teachers: 680
  • Students per Teacher: 12.2
  • Staff: 1396
  • Students: 8278

Private Schools in Zip Code 33040 (KEY WEST)

* This list of schools may not match the property above.

Grace Lutheran School 2713 Flagler Ave. Key West, FL 33040 Phone: 3052968262 PreK-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 150
  • Knd: 10
  • 1st: 2
  • 2nd: 3
  • 11th: 2
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 165
Mary Immaculate Star Of The Sea School 700 Truman Ave. Key West, FL 33040 Phone: 3052941031 PreK-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 32
  • Knd: 17
  • 1st: 24
  • 2nd: 18
  • 3rd: 21
  • 4th: 23
  • 5th: 15
  • 6th: 19
  • 7th: 24
  • 8th: 14
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 207
Montessori Children's School 1221 Varela St. Key West, FL 33040 Phone: 3052945302 PreK-12th
Grade Size Distribution
  • PreK: 70
  • Knd: 19
School Population
  • Teachers: 0
  • Students per Teacher: N/A
  • Students: 89

* School data provided by US Department of Education


Listing information is provided in part by the Internet Data Exchange (IDX) program of the Florida Keys Board of REALTORS®, Inc. The information on this website is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. Copyright 2017 Florida Keys Board of REALTORS®, Inc. All rights reserved.

* Rates and payment information listed in the mortgage calculator are provided as for general reference only. Specific mortgage information should be verified with a qualified lending professional